Rebellion is a way for people to express their dissatisfaction with their government. Throughout George Orwell’s 1984, Winston attempts to start a rebellion against the Party– an action that mirrors that of the American Revolution through the driving factors, political conditions, and steps towards success.
Oftentimes, extreme and controlling governments are the ones to experience rebellion. In 1984, Winston lives in the oppressive Oceania. The government, the Party, manages everything from portioning food rations to eliminating independent thoughts. In reference to this mind-control, Winston says, "Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two make four. If that is granted, all else follows" (Orwell 103 PDF). In history, before the Americans
…show more content…
Throughout the book, Winston becomes more outspoken about his hatred for Big Brother, as seen when Orwell writes, "And yet the rage that one felt was an abstract, undirected emotion which could be switched from one object to another like the flame of a blowlamp. Thus, at one moment Winston’s hatred was not turned against Goldstein at all, but, on the contrary, against Big Brother, the Party, and the Thought Police…" (Orwell 19 PDF). Similarly, Americans grew more angry with Britain as they continued to add relentless acts. This dissatisfaction lit the fire under the colonists in their fight for freedom: “These taxes, enacted without assent from the colonies, galvanized opposition to the British and led to colonial resistance" (Goldberg). In 1984, Winston largely disagrees with Big Brother and his policies. He wants to overthrow Big Brother for his constant abuse of power. Before the American Revolution, the colonists outwardly disagreed with the new taxes from Britain, resulting in events such as the Boston Tea Party and the Boston Massacre. Tensions continued to rise between the two nations, ultimately leading to the American …show more content…
Despite that there has never been a true “rebellion" against the Party, the government highlights a traitor, Emmanuel Goldstein. Even though Goldstein fails in overthrowing the government, he remains influential as he openly opposes Big Brother, “But what was strange was that although Goldstein was hated and despised by everybody, although every day and a thousand times a day, on platforms, on the telescreen, in newspapers, in books, his theories were refuted, smashed, ridiculed, held up to the general gaze for the pitiful rubbish that they were—in spite of all this, his influence never seemed to grow less" (Orwell 17 PDF). Conversely, Americans achieved their desired goals with their rebellions. These actions resulted in the Revolutionary War, which eventually led to freedom from Britain. The American success, however, did not come easily, "...the Americans prevailed due to their spirit and the fact that they were fighting for something they believed in. Popular support for the Revolutionary War was overwhelming. In the end, the British desire to maintain economic control over the colonies could not match the intense desire of the colonists to be independent and free" (“How Did the Americans Win the Revolutionary War?”). To win the American Revolution, it took the effort of hundreds of thousands of people who truly believed in gaining independence. Winston did not have the resources, nor the
British rule over the American colonies in the 1700s lead to an overall dissatisfaction, and in many cases, resentment, towards the British. The masses were fed up with British taxation and standing armies. The upper class was particularly displeased with the newly imposed economic restrictions. However, there were still a handful of colonists that believed going to war with Britain would jeopardize the little economic freedom that they did have. As a result, a number of colonists opposed the American Revolution, but the majority of colonists advocated for the fight for independence and freedom.
When Great Britain and the American colonies declared war, the colonists were viewed very unfavorably. Britain had the greatest navy and army in the world at the time. They were the most successful empire and had the most access to resources that could ensure their win. The colonists had none of this, and therefore, were predicted to be beaten terribly in their fight for independence. However, the colonists had factors that Great Britain did not have that would lead to their triumph in the revolution.
The American Revolution was a war of principles fought between the Loyalists and the Patriots. The Loyalists believed that they should stay loyal to the king because they didn't want to go into war. They didn't want to lose their fortune or businesses because if the Patriots won they would lose it all. Moreover, the Patriots fought for the principle of freedom. They fought for their rights.
Before the American Revolution, the British had appeared unstoppable. The thought that the colonies, who had existed completely at Britain’s will, could defeat them was astonishing. America gained their independence, despite the doubts. Without the tyranny of the British monarchy, the colonists had to establish a new government around the recently written Constitution. George Washington, one of the generals critical to the success of the revolution, was unanimously elected as the new leader.
The American Revolution started out with the colonists wanting to escape the monarchy to be in the new world. Unfortunately, the British didn’t make it easy on the colonists. Initially they supported
In George Orwell’s classic novel, 1984, Winston Smith is a secret rebel, fighting the control of Big Brother, who represents the overpowered, all knowing government. Winston is fighting more than his government though, he is fighting his entire society. Big Brother’s power comes from his ability to manipulate the masses, so influentially, that the masses work towards the oppression of themselves. In questioning Big Brother, Winston is questioning the entirety of known society. Winston meets others that share his views on society and expand Winston’s field of thought, leading him to make conclusions about his society; conclusions that lead to direct rebellion against Big Brother.
In the years 1765 to 1783 Americans were fighting for their independence. Britain finally decided to take its role as a mother country after many years of salutary neglect. The American Revolution was revolutionary because colonist fought for a change in the way the government was set up. The colonies were a part of Great Britain, so they still had to respond to Britain even if it was unfair. Britain's greatest mistake was taxing the colonists.
The American Revolutionary War was a time of great milestones for the American people. Under British rule, the colonists were treated poorly and unfairly, creating an uprising among the people that sparked a time of change. The colonists decided to fight back against the British rule and they considered the idea of becoming independent from Great Britain. On July 4, 1776 this important and renown document was first presented to the public, serving as a beacon of hope and change (Anonymous, N.d.). It is extremely important to remember what issues the colonists faced and realize the important value of this document.
In 1984 this represents rebellion as how Winston rebels against Big Brother and what Big Brothers believes ends, and how Winston fails to trust, fails to resist Big Brother, has a central conflict with the government, and how in 1984 there is no documentation of the people when they are vaporized .In 1984, George Orwell envisioned a bleak future state that banishes personal loyalties and manipulates memories of the people in Oceania into what Big Brother believes in. This represents rebellion as how Winston rebels against Big Brother and what Big Brothers believes ends, and how Winston fails to trust, fails to resist Big Brother, has a central conflict with the government, and how in 1984 there is no documentation of the people when they are vaporized.
At the time of the revolution, the colonist wanted to fight for their independence and the American identity they had already began to develop. The revolution started in 1765 as a result of many of the issues the colonists faced, such as the unfair taxations and high tensions that existed between them and the British. The war was long and hard, as the British army was very powerful. After seven long years of fighting, the Americans ended the war victorious and with an even stronger
In the end we shall make thoughtcrime literally impossible, because there will be no words in which to express it.” (Orwell, 55). As he stated, the Party aims to fully remove individual thought through narrowing down the
The American Revolution evolved from rising tensions between the British government and the 13 colonies who wished for independence. The people of America essentially wanted to be separated from Britain and desired self-government. An abundance of factors caused Americans to distrust Britain and there is not just one reason but many. The experiences of the Americans at the time, are what caused them to long for separation. Many people wonder, what were the most important causes of the American Revolution?
He writes of the British view of the rebellion and clears up the general idea of King George the Third being a witless king. In Britain, many well known British speakers supported the American cause yet still referred to America as “our colonies”. Arguments such as how the military tactics of the American Revolutionary War will proved to jumpstart future warfare can also be seen throughout the book. Although many arguments were presented throughout the book, one that the author presented stunningly was that without George Washington’s leadership, the American Revolutionary War would have certainly failed. Details throughout the book indicates that the war was more harsh than anyone could’ve imagined and during 1776, it felt like a lost cause.
Big Brother was never one to be questioned, and he made the consequences known to anyone who did so. Winston clearly expressed his hatred for Big Brother and all of the restrictions placed on members of society in the beginning of the book. Despite this, he constantly hid his facial expressions and thoughts from the telescreens, in great fear that the thought police would catch him. Contrary to that outward conformity, he was always inwardly questioning Big Brother. He directly broke the law by writing in a journal, especially since
At the beginning of the novel, Winston made it prominent that he dissented Big Brother and his party’s idea. He wrote in his diary, in Book 1 Chapter 1, “DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER…” (Orwell 18). This shows that Winston dissented his country’s government and was willing to rebel for he knew deep inside that