What is the “model minority” stereotype? It is a common portrayal amongst Asian American students that suggests they are more academically and economically successful than other races. It is believed they are more successful than other minority groups because their cultures value hard work. Throughout the Second Edition of Unraveling the “Model Minority” Stereotype, Stacey Lee investigates this stereotype by examining the population of “Asian American” students at Academic High School.
Soon after her arrival, Lee discovers the students divided themselves into distinctive groups: Koreans, Asians, Asian Americans, or New Wavers. The Korean-identified students thought of themselves as superior and distanced themselves from all other Asians. They
…show more content…
33). They did everything in their power to become closer to white students by mimicking the way they dress, the music they listen to, and the activities they participated in. The Asian-identified students included the majority of the Asian Americans attending Academic High. They were diverse in ethnicity and came from an assortment of social classes. They associated solely with other students of Asian descent because they “shared cultures” (Lee, 2009, p. 39). They believed it was important for all Asians to work hard, get good grades and keep themselves out of trouble. They also held a deep desire to earn respect from white Americans and “did not challenge discrimination or speak directly about inequality” (Lee, 2009, p. 40). By doing so the Asian-identified students kept to themselves and accepted the discrimination in hopes of getting ahead. The Asian American identified students were compiled of a range of ethnic groups and social classes. They were strong academically and believed they had the most in common with other Asian-American students, although they saw themselves as American. Unlike the Asian students, the Asian Americans …show more content…
According to Tatum, prejudice is “preconceived judgment or opinion, usually based on limited information” (Tatum 67). While racism is the belief that one’s race is superior to another. Prejudice is derived from limited information and is formed based on beliefs or misconceptions of others. Racism stems from information already possessed about a certain race. Once racism is present within a person it seems that the hatred stems so deep that it is hard to change it. Throughout Tatums piece she does speak of other minorities but, the basis of her arguments surrounds African Americans. Contradicting Tatum’s article, Lee states that “racial subordination of blacks have lead most Americans to equate blackness with minority status”(Lee, 2009, p. 4). She also argues that “people speak of ‘American’ as if it means ‘white’ and ‘minority’ as if it means ‘black’" (Lee, 2009, p. 6). Because of this “black-white racial paradigm” other minorities like Asian Americans are left out of discussions of race. (Lee, 2009, p. 4). Tatum continues to states that, “people of color are not racist because they do not systematically benefit from racism” but, Stacey Lee’s work at Academic High reveals differently (Tatum, 246). The different groups of Asian American students had their own racist views of other minorities as well as other Asian American students. The Korean-identified students “held
In Beverly Tatum’s, Defining Racism: “Can We Talk?” she states the difference between racism and prejudice. According to Tatum, prejudice is “preconceived judgment or opinion, usually based on limited information” (Tatum 67). While racism is the belief that one’s race is superior to another. Prejudice is derived from limited information and is formed based on beliefs or misconceptions of others.
In this memo I will be going over Higher Education Debates dealing with the fears of Asian quotas being imposed; as well as going over why there seems to be a trend of Asian-American parents who are more biased towards prestigious colleges. For the first article regarding Asian quotas, I will be summarizing and reflecting upon the six arguments whether it is believed that certain Ivy league schools impose a quota on the Asian-American population or not. As for the piece dealing with Asian American parent preferring Ivy League schools for their children, I will briefly summarize and discuss the cultural reasons why Asian-American parents are highly selective over their college choices for their children. In Ron Unz’s debate, he provides statistical evidence indicating that Ivy league schools place quotas on the Asian-American population
I have chosen to do this reading response of Lee’s piece about model minorities. This chapter focuses on stereotyping of Asian American students and the affects that that has. This piece starts off by discussing how there are two main stereotypes of Asian Americans and those are: being the foreigner and the model minority. Next, the piece discusses how Asian Americans are not seen as authentic, which has resulted in modifications to try and achieve the “American” standard of beauty. I believe that the central argument of this piece is showing that stereotyping Asian americans is detrimental to their education and their identity.
Reading Reflection Paper #1 The intersection of race, family, war torn experience and cultural diversity have played a crucial role in shaping many Hmong Americans and their acculturation to American society. With the racial tension that has long grouped Hmong students as part of the American model minority stereotypes, this has hampered Hmong students’ success in K-12 schools, and it is long overdue for academic discourse in order to propel Hmong students’ educational success into new heights. It is no longer acceptable for school district to accept the model minority stereotypes and ignore the fact that Hmong students has long struggled and underserved in public schools.
Vietnam National University, Hanoi University of Languages and International Studies Faculty of Linguistics and Culture of English speaking countries Final paper VIETNAMESE PEOPLE LIVING IN THE US: STRAINS AND CONTRIBUTIONS Student: Tran Luu Ly Class: 13E16 Teacher: Nguyen Hai Ha With globalization resulting in the increased movement of people around the globe, immigration has become a significant matter in most developed countries. In the United States, Asian American immigrants, accounting for about 5.6% of the total population (2010), is also the fastest growing group in the States. Similar to other minorities, the flow of Vietnamese immigrants has been rising over the last century, and this group is said
The teacher then relates it to each race’s culture. She states that families that are Asian and Jewish stress the importance of education while Black families do not. This direct connection between culture and success causes several racial problems between the different races (Lee, 2009). Although Asian Americans are expected to do well across these socioeconomic aspects there is data that proves otherwise. Several studies have shown that Asian Americans earn less money than Whites despite having equal qualifications.
Delgado and Stefancic (2011) stated that Critical Race Theory explores how “race, racism, and power intersect to create different circumstances for people of color within society [...] and in postsecondary institutions” (as cited in Quaye, 2013, p. 172). Within the field of higher education, it is important for student affairs professionals to recognize how race permeates all aspects of an individual’s life to fully understand their students’ experiences. Unlike other student development theories, such as Baxter-Magolda’s (2008) self-authorship and Abes, Jones, and McEwen’s (2007) Model of Multiple Identities, CRT places race at the “center of the analysis and assumes that race is omnipresent” in an individual’s life (Quaye, 2013, p. 167).
Throughout the piece “Campus Racism 101” by Nikki Giovanni, the concept of ignorance is evaluated and advice to minority students is given. Giovanni, a professor at Virginia Tech, describes the struggles that might, and most likely will, impact minority students and addresses the stereotypical mindset that those students, and Giovanni herself, will encounter while on campus and in the “real world”. Giovani uses imagery to set the stage of her piece “Campus Racism”, as well as logical and backed by real world experience advice to students to help minority students succeed in predominately white colleges. Giovanni first uses imagery to set the stage for stereotypes and the issue of racism on college campuses. At first this seems irrelevant as she describes a young man who is “Too cool for school.
Tan noted that in general, Asian Americans perform better on math and science achievement exams than on English ones. The low representation could be the result of Asian American students who use broken or limited English being steered away from writing into math and science. Similarly, in “The Myth of the Latin Woman: I Just Met a Girl Named María”, stereotypes and popular portrayals of Latina women as domestics or waitresses have partially led to the denial of opportunities for upward mobility among Latinas in the professions. Whether misrepresentations are brought on by the analysis of someone’s appearance or their linguistic abilities, those stereotypes and misjudgments can hinder the potential for growth and success of an individual within their
Being raised as an Vietnamese, Asian American in the Silicon Valley is a permanent part of my identity. My ethnicity continuously impacts the way I view everyday functions varying from feeling uncomfortable when my friend walks into my house without immediately greeting my mother to feeling a minute sense of comfort once someone speaks Vietnamese. Although being American is a somewhat unifying race, my ethnicity permanently helps me differentiate myself from others. Nevertheless, both, my ethnicity and race, aid my ability to fully embrace the erratic patterns that the world may throw at me. A visible trait of mine that most people can see is that I am cisgender and a female.
There’s a myth about Asian Americans, that generalizes them into one group. People create false images of us through stereotypes. These stereotypes have been manifested in books, movies, and literature, but they have repercussions for Asian Americans in society. We are often treated as foreigners, people leading us to believe that we don’t belong in American society, and that we have no purpose being here. Stereotypes are natural things that people will talk about.
Racial Praising Your skin color is actually seen as a way to identify yourself but people also start judging you and give you a stereotypical outcome. “You’re Asian so your smart” is what people normally get at. Being an Asian such as myself, I get that a lot, specifically on math. It’s not that Asians are smart but that they work hard and that the expectations of their parents are a lot higher.
One of their findings were that the difference between Asian and White students GPA was due to their effort for their academic success, rather than cognitive advantages in either group. Asian students were over the White students in almost all the grades. However, there was a clear difference in their motivation and effort for getting good
By assuming that academic success is a guarantee and not something that needs the be worked hard for in order to achieve, it can be really damaging for either said of the spectrum. Both students who succeed and students who do not. Shankar continues to say “this stereotype not only keeps same Asian American students from being considered “normal” but also leaves others to struggle to accomplish the high standards associated with the term.” When students fail to reach the high standards put upon them by family or society they are cast out, or stop trying, many of the students interviewed in the Shankar piece decided there was no longer to working hard in school because
Race and Ethnicity Reflection The article, “Another inconvenient truth: Race and ethnicity,” discusses important aspects that can aid teachers in understanding students from different cultures (Hawley & Nieto, 2010). To increase children’s academic knowledge, educators need to understand that children are unique. Thus, not all children learn the same way. The article provides insight of how race and ethnicity impacts the learner. It is vital for educators to understand these aspects in a student.