The Myth Of The Twelve Tribes Of Israel Sparknotes

947 Words4 Pages

The Myth of the Twelve Tribes of Israel In the article "The Myth of the Twelve Tribes of Israel," Andrew Tobolowsky argues that the idea of the twelve tribes of Israel as a distinct and cohesive unit is a myth. Tobolowsky contends that the biblical notion of the twelve tribes is a construct of post-exilic Israelite writers who were attempting to create a unified national identity. While Tobolowsky's argument is certainly compelling, it is not without its critics. In this paper, we will examine Tobolowsky's claims and evaluate their merits. Tobolowsky begins his argument by noting that the biblical text does not present a consistent picture of the twelve tribes. For example, the tribe of Levi is often excluded from lists of the twelve tribes, …show more content…

For example, the twelve tribes were often used as a symbol of the Israelites' covenant relationship with God, and they were frequently invoked in ancient Israelite literature and poetry. In addition, Tobolowsky's argument overlooks the fact that the concept of the twelve tribes has played an important role in Jewish and Christian tradition for centuries. The idea of the twelve tribes as a cohesive unit has been a powerful symbol of Jewish and Christian identity, and it has been invoked in countless works of art, literature, and theology. While it is certainly important to critically examine the historical origins of this concept, it is also important to recognize its enduring significance in contemporary culture. Despite these criticisms, Tobolowsky's argument has several strengths. One strength is that it challenges traditional assumptions about the nature of ancient Israelite society. Tobolowsky's argument suggests that the Israelites were not a unified nation with a shared history and destiny, but rather a collection of tribes with individual identities and allegiances. This challenges the traditional view of Israelite society as a monolithic entity and encourages scholars to consider the complexity and diversity of ancient Israelite

Open Document