“You May Lay to That”: Honor Promoted in Treasure Island When Robert Louis Stevenson first wrote Treasure Island, the title of the book was Sea Cook (Hardesty and Mann). The author’s original title alludes to the centrality of the character Long John Silver, the mutinous Sea Cook. Silver is a problem character from the beginning, as enigmatic as he is charismatic. There is embedded in Silver a curious question of morals and value in trust. In reference to Silver, Lisa Honaker remarks that Stevenson has made “the villain the hero of Treasure Island” (29). However, an examination of the reader’s response to the characters of Jim Hawkins and Long Silver together will reveal instead that it is the duality of these two characters which create the …show more content…
The character of Long John Silver is constructed deliberately from ambiguity in the very beginning of the story, when Billy Bones pays Jim Hawkins to keep a “weather-eye open for a seafaring man with one leg” (Stevenson 3). This elusive attitude of wariness continues throughout. Silver becomes something more than himself: it is remarked that all were afraid of Captain Flint, but even Flint was afraid of Silver. Thus he is distinguished in the reader’s mind as distinct from the other pirates-- more intelligent, less base, more admirable, less vile. The distinction from other pirates and the enigma produce in readers a sort of admiration and allows for a construction of who the real Silver might be. Of the many pirate phrases employed by Silver, one of the most common is: “You may lay to that.” According to “Treasure Island: Chapter Notes”, this is “a phrase common in John Silver's dialect, and meaning "You may depend upon that" (Baker). Ironically, there is not much that Silver does that you may depend upon. His ability to fool Dr. Livesey and company in the beginning as an honest sea cook, and switch just as easily to a vicious and persuasive Captain for the mutineers contributes to an ever changing mask which one cannot trust. Jim observes this mutability when the mutineers find the treasure:
In the 1850s there were many different views about slavery in the north and south. Some people wanted to keep slavery, known as abolitionists, while others wanted to put an end to it. William Lloyd garrison and Fredrick Douglass thought slavery was cruel and needed to be ended while others including James Hammond thought slavery was a necessary part of government. The opinions of whether or not to keep or end slavery were shared in books, articles, and speeches. Some people believed slavery was right and some believed it was wrong.
“Was it fair, was it honorable, that a half-pay surgeon should take such advantage of an intimacy which chance brought about? Might she not look upon me as a mere vulgar fortune-seeker?” The treasure has Watson questioning what he could offer Mary if she did become that wealthy, what he could offer her if she jumped him in social standing and wealth. Watson regains his masculinity and Mary returns to a traditional gender role after the treasure is no longer looming over
In Daniel Gumbiner’s “The Boatbuilder,” Garrett, like many characters in the story, is one of great complexity and his actions frequently present a conundrum on whether he just makes human mistakes or is genuinely a bad person. This discussion will clearly show with evidence why he is the latter by delving into the complexities of his actions and also his character. It is understandable why a reader could be inclined to believe that he is just a troubled individual. However, throughout the story, he displays his manipulative and harmful behavior by crossing the line from making what could be seen as simple mistakes to being actually malevolent on multiple occasions. By exploring themes of morality, personal responsibility, and the impact of
Zoie Collinson Mrs. Gonder ENG4U May 11th, 2015 Do as I say, not as I do. A comparative essay. Do as I say, not as I do. Religious hypocrisy can be described as: Using the values, virtues and beliefs of religion to motivate and manipulate others while degrading these things in one's behavior.
The novel is about the adventures of the protagonist, Huckleberry Finn, and Jim, a runaway slave, and their encounters/rendezvous with these people to achieve their main goal of setting Jim free. From the beginning of the novel, the reader
One occurrence that proves this theme is that in which Huckleberry Finn attempts to write a letter to Miss Watson, Jim’s former owner, notifying her of Jim’s location in order
First published in serial format in 1881-82 and then in book form in 1883, Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island has become a worldwide classic (Works of Robert Louis Stevenson). The story of a boy who gets mixed up with a gang of pirates, it has been read by generations of eager children and has been adapted into movie form a half-dozen times. As is the case with all classic literature, the question arises as to why this particular work has endured when others, perhaps just as well-written, have been forgotten. In the case of Treasure Island, many elements combined to make it a popular classic to this day. It is a coming-of-age story, a hero’s journey, and a saga of pirates, the fascinating outlaws of the sea.
He is not interested in the novel until his instructor mentions the critics of the novel and where it should end. Similar to these critics, the class debates whether Twain’s ending draws away from his critique of Racism and Graff found that even famous authors were capable of mistakes that could be found at his level. Now that the author has controversies to watch out for, he is able to draw a personal engagement form the books he reads as the arguments of critics guided his reading. Due to the controversy over Twain’s novel, the author then has a realization that reading and intellectual discussion could have an effect on his life, and he became less embarrassed about doing such
Democracy or Theocracy? The first amendment of the Constitution states: “ Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” The separation of church and state allows religious people to have the same rights and freedoms as every other person. No special privileges, no exceptions.
Jim also resembles the Long John Silver from treasure island in a sense because he is very close with Huck like long john sliver with the young boy Jim. They both teach the young boys what they knew helped them out respected them. But long john sliver was more a anti hero in a sense when Jim was more always good to Huck but they
` As Joe’s excitement mounted to give rides on his newly purchased boat, his joy soon turned to dread as one of his beloved passengers tumbled into the water. The author, Horatio Alger Jr., of “Joe’s Reward” writes a story of a hero named Joe, who rescues a wealthy man’s niece that ends with an offer of a reward. The text consists of Joe’s actions that happen to drive the plot using specific events. Throughout the story, Horatio uses myth-like elements, such as a damsel in distress, a heroic act, and the hero receiving and turning down a reward, to assist the plot in moving forward.
Using a mixture of realistic and non-realistic scenarios in his story, Wells was able to create a roller coaster ride, and pull the readers deeper into the twists and turns of the novel. Through the plot, the perceptions of characters, and the overall message of The Invisible Man, readers
Parks has interpreted Thomas’s thoughts for us, the reader, helping us to continue our familiarisation with the characters voice and personality. This then helps us understand the emotions of the characters, therefore enhancing our understanding of the
Treasure Island, by Robert Louis Stevenson, is about a young boy that happens across a treasure map due to some peculiar circumstances. Before he stumbles across this, however, he had to deal with “the captain”. Billy Bones, also known as the captain, showed up one day to the Admiral Benbow. And that is when young Jim Hawkin’s journey began. Some refer to the meaning of this adventure as Jim’s journey to becoming a man.
Pirates in movies are depicted as having a great bond. After all, crews spends months at a time together on a ship with only each other and the ocean. However, many crews, friendships, and even families can be torn apart by a simple, deadly killer: greed. In the nineteenth century novel Treasure Island, by Robert Louis Stevenson, the protagonist Jim, a young boy from Bristol, England, meets pirate Captain Billy Bones, who dies at the family 's inn, leading Jim to the treasure map hidden in the Captain’s chest. With the help of a local doctor and lord, the three round up a crew and a ship to sail to the hidden treasure on the map.