Identity of Hamlet
Hamlet by William Shakespeare is one of the most historical in English literature. Some so many philosophers have different understandings based on Hamlet's story, even the directors have different scenes in their movies but the same line story between the story and the act. Also, there are times when Hamlet shows signs of madness scene by scene. Colin McGinn’s theory uses another theory from David Hume that talks about self and identity to help his theory. What McGinn says about it is all about the perception of others toward us everyone that we need other perception to know or differentiate the impression that other people give, where Hamlet tries to know and want to know everything. I agree with McGinn’s theory that the
…show more content…
Hamlet is about to show his goals. McGinn questions that “What might Hamlet attempt to be true to his own nature as he begins his quest to revenge for his father’s murder?” (59) Hamlet does not understand why he cannot carry out his revenge for his father and that is why after he can talk to his father who already dies even after his revenge fulfill his revenge, he thought his problem would resolve even after he killed the killer of his father as he said “So, uncle, there you are. Now to my word: It is “Adieu, adieu. Remember me.” I have sworn’t” (Shakespeare 1.5.110). The play contains numerous accidents including dramatic irony, and in the center of the story, that is the mystery of Hamlet’s goals that makes us think. Whether he is a dreamer or a murderer; is he truly mad or is he only pretending? because it is hard to understand the character of Hamlet itself, nearly impossible “He is impossible to pin down” (McGinn 41). And when the ghost says to Hamlet “Leave her to heaven and to those thorns that in her bosom lodge to prick and sting her” (Shakespeare 1.5.89) the ghost asks Hamlet to not hurt his mother for her actions to make her try to tell his family that he will kill Claudius “as I perchance hereafter shall think meet to put on an antic disposition” (Shakespeare 1.5.58) from disposition Hamlet is trying to dethrone …show more content…
Hamlet is getting stressed in his relationship when Hamlet says “Get thee to a nunnery. Why wouldst thou be a breeder of sinners? I am myself indifferent honest, but yet I could accuse me of such things that it were better my mother had not borne me” (Shakespeare 3.1.118). This could be one of the worst things in his life by showing that he acts annoyed by knowing his mother married again with Claudius after his father's death and he humiliates his own mother. While McGinn adds “His mother has thus betrayed his father, and this has moved him to his painful melancholy.” (43) how can Hamlet accept this when he is still in mourn of his father and throw away the love that she shows to his father while they are still together. Moreover, his relationship with Ophelia is argumentative about whether Hamlet loved Ophelia until she is dead where McGinn also expresses “As with his varying behavior towards Ophelia. Does he love her or not? There is really no saying. Then there is a question of his madness.” (40) Hamlet faced so many obstacles to knowing his love for Ophelia, he ends up transferring his anger to Ophelia. Meanwhile, Hamlet says this to Ophelia “That if you be honest and fair, your honesty should admit no discourse to° your beauty.” (Shakespeare 3.1.115) He states that beauty is not important to him but how competent she is. This makes Hamlet is being crazier with the situation
By verbally harassing Ophelia and estranging himself from her, Hamlet provides the apparent image of losing his prior care without a great amount of consideration. Additionally, Hamlet further displays his anger for his father’s death through this display. By dissolving his relationship with Ophelia, Hamlet furthers his image of insanity to further illustrate himself as incapable within Claudius’s eyes while still communicating distaste for his loss of his father. With Hamlet’s intentionally swift change of heart for Ophelia, Hamlet’s procedure warrants a certain level of sanity. Regardless of the sudden nature, Hamlet’s continual barring from Ophelia possesses procedure which causes further doubt of Hamlet’s mental instability from the audience of the
To find out if the ghost is trustworthy of his accusations, Hamlet fabricates two plans. He first decides to act “mad” for others to start to ignore his ways and how he acts “To put an antic disposition on” (Shakespeare I.v. 192). He then decides to add a few more lines to an upcoming play that is performed in the kingdom. He makes Horatio watch to see if there was any reaction from King Claudius. After Hamlet executes his scene of the possible murder, Claudius reacts in an unmannered way letting Hamlet confirm the Ghosts' acquisitions.
By having the Ghost speak in such a hateful, and passionate manner about Claudius and Gertrude, Shakespeare can convey Hamlet's feelings toward them without the need for extensive dialogue on Hamlet's end. Although Hamlet is nearly silent for the majority of his father's speech, it is clear by a combination of the little words Hamlet does speak, and his father's uninterrupted fury that Hamlet is enraged by this knowledge. The language used in the speech provides Hamlet with the reasoning which dictates his motivation and actions throughout the play and introduces the major theme of revenge, serving as a call to action for Hamlet. While the ghost heavily encourages his son to avenge his murder, he is careful to warn Hamlet of the dangers of revenge. He warns Hamlet not to wrongfully unleash his revenge on his mother.
King Hamlet loved Gertrude with all his heart that he “might not beteem the winds of heaven visit her face too roughly” this represents true unforgettable love. Hamlet is exasperated about his mother’s hasty marriage that he claims a “beast that wants discourse of reason would have mourned longer”. Gertrude’s hasty marriage with Claudius seems to Hamlet as done with “wicked speed to post with such dexterity to incestous sheets” showing Hamlet is disgusted with this relationship and aggressively disapproves to this action. Further into the play Act 3 Scene 2, Hamlet is having a conservation with Ophelia when he mentions “look you how cheerfully my mother looks, and my father died within two hours” showing anger towards the happiness of his mother. Throughout the play Hamlet uncovers horrible deeds his uncle has committed, which were “Remorseless, Treacherous, lecherous”.
Hamlet once again fails to understand that Ophelia much like himself is only trying to stay loyal to her father, much like what he is doing himself. In addition, Hamlet blames woman for giving birth to such evil and deceiving men like Claudius and himself. When he was talking to Ophelia he told her "Get thee to a nunnery. Why wouldst thou be a breeder of sinners? I am myself indifferent honest, but yet I could accuse me of such things that it were better
Instead of taking action and killing claudius, he questions whether the ghost was actually his father asking to revenge his death or the devil resembling his father to try to tempt him into murder. In No Fear Shakespeare from Sparknotes, Hamlet talks about his doubts to believe the ghost is actually his father or not by saying “May be the devil, and the devil hath power T’ assume a pleasing shape. Yea, and perhaps Out of my weakness and melancholy, As he is very potent with such spirits, Abuses me to damn me (Act 2 Scene 2 Page 24). This shows how Hamlet was indecisive and how the ghost of his father was one of the major reasons why he was indecisive.
When Hamlet meets with the ghost King Hamlet in the opening scene, he realizes that his father is murdered by Claudius. From Act I scene 5, the ghost King Hamlet is asking Hamlet to seek for revenge, “So art thou to revenge, when thou shalt hear” (1.5.12). By knowing this, Hamlet starts the revenge for his father and sets the tone of the entire play where death, revenge, murder, and suicide become the symbols of the whole play, and leads to the deaths of almost all the characters, including Claudius, Laertes, Polonius, Ophelia, Queen Gertrude, Rosencrantz, Guildenstern, and Hamlet himself. Also, because of his father’s death and his mother’s quick marriage with Claudius, Hamlet has the idea of committing suicide. From Act I scene 2, "O, that this too sullied flesh would melt,Thaw, and resolve itself to dew" (1.2.133-134).
In Act III, scene i of The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark by William Shakespeare, readers will come upon Ophelia’s soliloquy. After Rosencrantz and Guildenstern have failed to find a reason as to why Hamlet is acting in a peculiar and mad way, Claudius is persuaded by Polonius that the reason for Hamlet’s madness is the broken romance between Hamlet and Ophelia. To prove this, Claudius and Polonius plan to spy on Ophelia’s meeting with Hamlet. During their conversation, Hamlet denies ever having loved her and curses her. Ophelia is left fretting over his sanity.
Saying this, Hamlet’s behavior towards Ophelia is crude, rough, and full of anger. Despite Hamlet’s harsh treatment towards Ophelia, he really did love her, but because she was not his main focus, the
Along with avenging his death, the Ghost asks Hamlet to perform another task and says, “But howsoever thou pursuest this act, Taint not thy mind, nor let thy soul contrive Against thy mother aught” (1.5.84-85). The Ghost’s assurance of Gertrude’s safety appeals to Hamlet because Hamlet loves his mother and shows willingness to protect her. However, if the Ghost had said negative remarks about Gertrude, he would not follow the Ghost’s wishes. Furthermore, this request by the Ghost makes Hamlet emphasize family throughout the play, and it also fuels his revenge for his father. Also, the Ghost tells Hamlet how his brother betrayed him in order to become king by stating, “The serpent that did sting thy father’s life Now wears his crown” (1.5.39-40).
In act one Gertrude marries her dead husband 's brother Claudius, Hamlet is not very happy that his mother did this. Hamlet feels very betrayed by his own mother because she remarried so quickly. He feels as if this is an unforgivable
Hamlet, considered by most readers and many critics as the best play ever written, is centered around a main character whose identity is highly debated. Although the play is widely considered by many as the greatest play of all time, his is up in the air and most would not look down upon another for having a different interpretation of Hamlet’s identity. The cause of this is the sheer amount of interpretations that can be drawn from the play. These interpretations also cause the question: “Who is Hamlet?” to become one of the hardest questions to answer.
Hamlet brings to go on and talk about how much her and how beautiful she was. He then tells her he doesn’t love her, but it can be assumed that he said so because Hamlet knew they were being watched by Pulonious, asking Ophelia where her father was. Hamlet has shown many instances where he would fake an act just to confuse others. Another instance is when he quotes “never doubt I love” (II.ii.127). He tells her despite all the false things happening around them, his love for her was a genuine.
In the end, Hamlet does take revenge for his father’s murder knowing he will not have to struggle with the throne. The theme of revenge in Hamlet is seen through many of the characters and is necessary for the development of the main characters. Hamlet, Laertes, and Fortinbras all seek revenge for the deaths of their fathers. Initially, after the murders, each one knew what they were going to do to take action and obtain vengeance.
Hamlet operates by deception which is constructed by a battle within himself that bears the question, “Kill Claudius or spare his life?’. This battle comes about after an interaction with the ghost of his father that triggers him to be deceptive, ultimately leading to the total demolition of an empire. Each of these instances of deceit contributes to the message underlying the work as a whole, which reveals; revenge is not the answer. Deception is the driving force behind this play, which in its entirety, reveals that seeking vengeance and holding grudges is not the answer to life’s many mysteries. The character Hamlet converses with the ghost of his