Rhetoric as a Major Subject in Education
Argument, as Jay Heinrichs says, surrounds us. The study and practice of argument, rhetoric, once a major component of any well-rounded scholar’s education, has begun to be phased out of most curriculums today. To eliminate the studies of such a skill, a skill needed so often, is an ignorant move on the education board’s part. Rhetoric, the basis of almost all communication skills, should be reintroduced as a core credit in a student’s education.
If recognized, argument can be found in almost every interaction—people and animals or even inanimate objects utilize argument regularly. I can tell you before I had read Heinrichs’ book, Thank You for Arguing, I had never realized just how prevalent many
…show more content…
While my class was recounting their experiences with rhetoric in real life at the beginning of the semester, one classmate talked about the placement of audial adverts between songs on Spotify. He said the way the advertised services and merchandise had been presented had, instead of increasing his interest in the product, made him disinterested and even frustrated. Furthermore, in a survey on decision influences by consumers, television ads were said to have a high influence on purchase decisions 18% of the time, and a medium influence 47% of the time, whereas radio ads (such as Spotify’s) were only highly influential 5% of the time and moderately influential 32% of the time. (Erickson). Having a firm grasp on the benefits and disadvantages of different types of argument in different situations is a lucrative ability, and through rhetorical skill practice in schools, many students can be able to develop the skills for themselves.
Rhetorical analysis should be brought back as a staple in education because the class can teach people to become better-informed citizens, make better arguments at the right time, and can even improve grades in literature or analysis based
In “Re-Composing Space: Composition’s Rhetorical Geography,” Roberta Brinkley and Marissa Smith expose the how valid modern day rhetoric is by analyzing the work of professionals who specialize in the following: history, English, and human behavior. According to the authors, in ancient Greece only educated, white, non-slave, men were the only group whose opinion was considered; anyone’s opinion who did not meet that criteria did not matter. Brinkley and Smith believe that there are a lot of ideas that may have been missed due to this notion and also rings to question the credibility and the morals of the ancient Grecians. In order to convince students of rhetoric who have been taught their entire life the ‘correct’ way to make a valid argument
Grant Pendergraft Mrs. Erwin English II 20 January 2023 Jay Heinrichs is Very Good at Arguing Thank You for Arguing, by Jay Heinrichs, but more specifically, his section Remember Aristotle’s definition of virtue: A matter of character, concerned with choice, lying in a mean, is a persuasive essay on implementing rhetoric back into the curriculums of schools. He believes that if the population was taught rhetoric, the community would change for the better. He believes that when rhetoric is introduced into society, we will be less susceptible to tricks that currently fool us. This includes everything from candy bar ads, to American politics.
This essay is an analysis of Thank You For Arguing by Jay Heinrichs, a full-time advocate for the lost art of rhetoric. The three major topics to cover are which tools he uses frequently, which chapter was the most valuable and crucial to arguing effectively, and the argument for the book’s continued use or refutation of its value. Jay Heinrichs is teaching us the art of persuasion and other tools that come with it. Heinrichs uses many famous people, from Bart Simpson to Aristotle, to send his message and teach about The Art of Persuasion.
Rhetoric 101 isn't just any ordinary class but one of the more unique class that many students take at their first year of college. Mr. Klein especially makes the class what everyone one calls rhetoric an awesome class. Mr. Klein is a well respected professor that takes learning to the next level with his unique way of teaching unlike many other college professors do. His way of teaching makes everyone interact with any topic we talk about in class and makes everything clear and simple. Many students online rate Mr. Klein an excellent professor according to ratemyprofessor.
For many years, companies have utilized advertising as a useful tool to promote their brands, convey a message, or sell their products. In today’s world, advertisements can be seen almost everywhere from enormous billboards along highways to a diminutive ads on a phone. But not all advertisements are successful. To convey a message, advertisements must contain rhetorical devices such as pathos, logos, and ethos. A good example of how rhetorical devices are used to persuade an audience is the Edward Jones “Nine Days” commercial.
Throughout the first month of class, I’ve learn many concepts from the assignments given which include ethos,logos, pathos,claims,rhetorical reading and writing and others. One concept I have grasp is rhetorical reading, which means persuading the audience to believe a certain value or idea ultimately is considered an argument. For example,as I analyzed the content in the article Hidden Intellectualism by Gerald Graff, I had developed the conclusion that the author attempted to convince his audience to agree with his claim, which in fact his belief was that street smarts should absolutely be valuable academically in schools. After analyzing the article thoroughly, I had the task of writing a rhetorical essay explaining if I agree with the point
Listening to what their audience wanted? All of the attributes that made these people successful in rhetoric are topics that are discussed and broken down in Thank You For Arguing. For these reasons, I agree with the continued usage of this book. This skill is one that could accompany students for the rest of their lives for the greater good, and make a difference in their future careers. People like being told what they need and the way it’s presented to
If you perceive carefully, you will recognize it. Further, you can find that it deeply influences your writing. To illustrate, reading a great number of rhetoric contents allows you to accumulate the knowledge of writing. It also serves as a great training for the writer to use the strategies, such as proving with the confirmed recourse, in order to make one become a credible writer. • Describe a recent writing experience or activity where you used rhetoric to effectively convey a message to a specific audience?
“Education is the key to success” is a common phrase said by many of our millennial cohorts. The idea that education is a critical component of acquiring an eminent lifestyle has dated back since premodern times. Individuals are now constantly enrolling in postsecondary institutions in hopes of attaining endless opportunities along with the implied benefits that results from a college degree. Nevertheless, a college education is, unfortunately, not accessible to all people. In “The Diploma Divide,” Kassie Bracken explores the major disparity among low income students and their affluent counterparts on obtaining a postsecondary degree in the U.S. With the employment of an alluring appeal to one’s emotions, a use of despondent word choices to establish a dispirited ambience, and a distinguished platform to elucidate the author’s thoughts, Kassie effectively promoted her argument on how a college education is not attainable for all individuals.
My argumentative its self was filled with rhetoric in the sense that every paragraph had some form of rhetoric. Not only did it show me how essential rhetoric is in papers, but it help me form an appreciation for rhetoric. In my writing 10 major writing assignment one I did an argumentative paper. In my argumentative paper I wrote about something very important to me, and that was the division that our country is now facing between both sides of the political spectrum and even genders. So throughout this piece it is very evident that rhetoric is being used in our daily lives such as movements like "Black lives matter" and "Make America great again".
The first section of your syllabus entitled “What We’re Doing in This Course, and Why” intrigued me. Specifically, due to its mention of the concept of rhetorical thinking being used to figure out what to say and how to say it. To me, this section encompasses all disciplines who tend to use different words to describe how you present an argument both in a correct and incorrect manner (framing, bias, logical fallacies ect.). I’m interested to see how different disciplines utilize this skill from simply being as bland and logical as possible such as in a scientific paper, or to making an effort to persuade an audience in a speech such as in a debate.
Dialogic vs. Monologic Rhetoric Most students have had at least one bad teacher during their time in school. Looking back, many of the classes I didn’t enjoy or struggled with had teachers who treated the classroom like it was a one-sided conversation. In that case the teacher is engaging in monologic conversation, and in this paper, I will be discussing why dialogic conversation is more beneficial to the listener than monologic. This will be supported by talking about how rhetoric has evolved from Aristotle to Bakhtin, Aristotle’s version of monologic conversation, and how dialogic conversation would be more helpful in situations such as the classroom.
Logic and Rhetoric Personal Narrative Rhetoric can be described as language that is persuasive toward an audience or group of people. However, when thinking about rhetoric the first thing that comes to mind is arguments; if logic and rhetoric are present during arguments, becoming a better arguer is guaranteed. Without knowing the principles of logic and rhetoric individuals might get arguing and fighting confused with each other. Throughout Thank You for Arguing, college professor and author Jay Henrichs explains to his audience how to argue effectively, without making the argument become a fight. When communicating with others it can be easy to get lost in our own thoughts, leading to failed communication.
Rhetorically Analyzing A Talk to Teachers A talk to teachers, written by James Baldwin, criticises the education system in the mid-1900s by directly sending a message to teachers about the flaws in the system. He argues that race should not hinder equality or the quality of education a child receives. Baldwin uses tone and diction that highlights the importance of his message. In addition, he uses several persuasion tactics to convince his audience of his ideas.
For example, when we write an essay, we need to show how the text convinces us of its position. As a citizen, it is important to use rhetorical analysis in our daily life. It is a great tool to sort out questions about politics and relationship. For example, during the election period, we should use rhetorical analysis to analyze the candidate’s message to critical thinking skill to determine whether or not their words are true.