Dustin Moir was subjected to a Mr. Big operation following the discovery of a young girl’s remains in 2006. Due to his confession during the investigation, he was convicted of first degree murder in 2010 following a jury trial. This case reflects the appeal of his charges with considerations to admissions during the subsequent covert investigation against him.
Review of the facts
In 2005 fourteen year old Chelsey Acorn left her foster home without permission and was last seen in Abbotsford. A year later, her remains were found in an isolated area off of the Coquihalla Highway. Two men that were known associates to her at the time of her death were Dustin Moir and his father Jesse west. Following the discovery of the remains, officers decided
…show more content…
Moir willingly complied. He claimed that all three of them drove to the isolated campsite area, where Acorn would subsequently be buried and during this drive they both had sex with her. Additionally, Moir stated that he set up a tent and dug a grave and proceeded to bound Acorn. Both his father and himself choked Acorn to death and then put her in the grave where they covered her in rocks. Upon examination of her body, in which Moir was not aware at the time, Acorn had suffered blows to the head. This fact aligned with the details of his confession to undercover …show more content…
Dudley’s statements contained inconsistencies. Further, it led to the belief that Dudley was simply trying to exonerate himself as a witness when giving his statement against Moir. In addition to Dudley, another key witness Mr. Gordon’s statements also had inconsistencies. Gordon claimed that he had given a shovel to Moir prior to Acorn’s death. This may lead the jury to believe that Moir’s involvement in Acorn’s murder was planned and deliberate (para. 27). It was later found that there was no direct evidence of this exchange between Gordon and Moir. Rather this exchange of the shovel occurred between Gordan and Mr.
The Unjust Criminal Case and Civil Implications Of the Timothy Masters Case On the eleventh day of February, in 1987, the body of thirty-seven year old Peggy Hettrick was drug through a park in Fort Collins, Colorado. Almost exactly Twenty-one years later on January 22, 2008 Timothy Masters was released from Buena Vista Prison after being exonerated of her murder. During that time span a whirlwind of criminal and moral injustices occurred, which eventually led the life sentence of an innocent man. All in all this was one of the greatest legal screw ups in Colorado’s history.
Ron Stone, a police drug informant disappeared on January 22nd 1977 only for his body to be found two months later on the banks of River Stanislaus, miles from Sonora. The victim had been working as a drug informant for narcotic detectives. His main duty was to set up Christopher Towler by introducing him to two undercover agents who would arrest him as he tried to sell them cocaine. The set up was successful and Towler was arrested and convicted on charges of selling cocaine. In the course of his trial and before his conviction, Towler had expressed his hatred for snitches and the fact that he believed that they should be killed.
On April 18, 1977, Leonard Peltier was found guilty of two accounts of first degree murder. He was sentenced to serve two consecutive terms of life imprisonment for the murders of two FBI agents. Despite the jury’s unanimous verdict, many individuals believe that Peltier is a victim of social injustice. The evidence used against Peltier is in many cases circumstantial and does not provide solid evidence to convict him. Whether or not he was responsible for the deaths of the two FBI agents, his case deserves to be viewed from other perspectives in addition to personal bias.
Twenty one year old Moira Evans, daughter of Oftgrove police chief Theo Evans, has been found brutally murdered on the edge of the Evans property. No physical evidence was found at the scene, but the police had their man regardless. Desmond Holmes. Moira was a very kind girl and tutored Desmond twice a week, and as per the usual she tutored him last night. The Oftgrove Police Department released that Desmond was the last person to see Moira alive, and that they would be charging him with first degree murder.
A search party went looking for evidence or signs and came across a vehicle that they believe belonged to Teresa. They immediately called the sheriff’s department and had a search done. The car was found on the Avery Salvage. Inside the car blood was found that belonged to Steven Avery. The keys to Teresa’s vehicle were found inside Steven’s home.
Assistant District Attorney John Norsetter concealed exculpatory evidence for close 11 years. Ralph Armstrong was convicted for rape and murder in 1995. John Norsetter was aware that Armstrong was not guilty of such tarrying crime, however, he remained silence even though he knew Armstrong was innocent. Back in 1995, a woman made a call to the district attorney testifying that Stephen Armstrong, who was Ralph’s cousin was the responsible of the crime. The prosecutor never told defense attorneys of such valuable information.
As with any criminal case, there are always a number of issues pertaining the stages of the crime and also the media and the general public’s opinion of the case. Many of the issues and explicit actions of certain individuals that had happened during the Corryn Rayney case had affected the interpretation of the case in someway for both government workers and the general public. By analysing the issues of the case, it allows a much more detailed view on the case and how most of the issues are linked in one way or another. One of the issues regarding this case was where a police officer had been found attempting to pressure forensic pathologists to alter their case reports to align with their best interests.
Born in Rowlett Texas, an American woman convicted of the murder of her son, Damon Routier, stands on death row awaiting execution by lethal injection . After police investigation, allegations point to Darlie Routier and Darin Routier for slaughtering their two sons for insurance money. Was keeping up with the joneses becoming a struggle? On June 6th police received a disturbing call of a mother in panic after finding her two sons Damon and Devon stabbed to death in the family's living room,claiming their was a brutal burglary that went completely out of hand .Police arrive to find Darlie Routier with major wounds and extreme bruising to her arms and face suggesting she was fighting for her life from the intruder.
On November 16, 2009, Fayetteville, North Carolina Police found the body of a missing 5-year-old, Shaniya Davis, with the help of assisting volunteers. Shaniya Davis was reported missing by her mother, Antoinette Davis, on November 10, 2009. Shaniya Davis was last seen on the security video at the Comfort Suites hotel in Sanford along with a man that was identified as Mario McNeill. McNeill was charged with first-degree kidnapping three days after the 5-year-old was reported missing. Antoinette Davis was charged with accusations that she prostituted her daughter.
Ted’s Head Graveyard On January, 11 1975 Caryn Campbell vanished from her ski resort in Colorado while on vacation with her husband and his two kids, unfortunately her nude body was found one month later in the Colorado mountains, investigators eventually linked her murder to Ted Bundy (Ted Bundy Biography). According to Dictonary.com a monster is a person who excites horror by wickedness, cruelty, etc. Ted Bundy is a human monster due to his socially deviant behavior and crime of murder, rape , kidnapping and necrophile, thus proving that human monsters are more frightening than fictional one in their creation of fear. In 1974 young women began to oddly disappear from their college campus on Washington state and Oregon without a trace.
The West Memphis Three are three young men, Damien Echols, Jessie Misskelley Jr., and Jason Baldwin, who were tried and convicted as teenagers for a triple homicide that they did not commit. Both Misskelley and Baldwin were sentenced to life imprisonment, Misskelley with two additional 20-year sentences, while Echols was to receive the death penalty. Many believe that the trial was, for lack of a better term, a “witch hunt”, due to the fact that there was very little and horribly careless sincere investigation carried out in order to attempt to prove the young men innocent, there were multiple interviews disregarded simply for the sake of upholding the false notion that the teenagers were guilty, and the majority of the world at this time
After a twelve-hour interrogation, Brenton Butler confessed to the murder of Mary Ann Stephens. A key claim made by the defense attorneys in this case was that this was a false confession, and after reaching a verdict of not guilty, the jury clearly agreed. The factors that led the false confession were laid out in a scene during the documentary. Instead of using the interview to discover the truth, the interrogators specifically sought out a confession from the suspect. They began the interrogation with the presumption that Brenton Butler was guilty.
It can be argued that the jury was not a proper representation of his peers. Along with other factual errors surrounding Dixon’s false conviction,
Investigators stated that the evidence Karr provided didn’t add up to what actual injuries JonBenet suffered
The article Three Trials for Murder by Nicholas Schmidle sheds light on the constitutional right of double jeopardy and questions whether the “military sidestep double jeopardy”? Schmide focuses on the case of Tim Hennis, which many consider being “extraordinary” since legal scholars view U.C. M. J actions to prosecute a military member for crimes committed outside the army as “problematic”. Furthermore, it questions whether Hennis’ rights were violated when he is prosecuted for a third time, after being convicted and acquitted for the same crime. Schmidle article gives specific inside of all three of Hennis trials, and ultimately leaves the readers to decide if the action of the U.C.M.J violated military jurisdiction and the double jeopardy clause.